34 Halloween Potluck Ideas for Dishes to Serve at Your Monster Mash

2021-08-27
34 Halloween Potluck Ideas for Dishes to Serve at Your Monster Mash

Heading to a Halloween bash? Choose from one of our big-batch appetizers, main dishes, or desserts. With crowd-pleasers like cheesy barbecue sliders, bacon-wrapped smokies, and even a PSL (pumpkin-spiced latte) bundt cake, these Halloween potluck ideas will make even the pickiest ghouls and goblins happy.

01 of 34

Spider Halloween Deviled Eggs

This eerie Halloween potluck idea may look like green-tinted deviled eggs, but they're hiding a spooky surprise. Once you've boiled your eggs, gently crack them and place them into a bowl with black food coloring. The result is egg whites that look like they've been coated with spider webs!

02 of 34

Pumpkin Cheese Ball

The holiday season is busy, and we could all use a make-ahead Halloween potluck recipe that comes together quickly. This pumpkin cheese ball recipe fits the bill. Create your own in just 15 minutes and chill until ready to serve.

03 of 34

Cider-Cheese Fondue

A bottle of hard cider is the secret to this creamy cheese fondue. The light apple flavor helps cut through the richness of the cheese. One reviewer shared a must-have hack for keeping the dish warm, "This cheese is amazing. It was so creamy. The cider flavor was perfect for fall. I used my instant pot to saute and keep warm since we don't have a fondue pot."

04 of 34

Halloween Dessert Nachos

Put all that Halloween candy to good use by whipping up a tray of these dessert nachos. Top sliced Granny Smith apples with melted peanut butter, jelly, and chopped chocolate candy. A sprinkle of candy eyes adds a spooky touch.

05 of 34

Marbled Chocolate-Pumpkin Brownies

These fudgy bars are part brownie and part cheesecake. We've topped our homemade brownie recipe with a creamy pumpkin cream cheese mixture. Spice them up with cinnamon, ginger, and vanilla. Once baked, cut them into a whopping 36 individual servings.

06 of 34

Pumpkin Spice Latte Bundt Cake with Whipped Cream

For many of us, it's not Halloween. It's PSL season. Bring the flavors of your favorite fall drink home in this easy bundt cake recipe. Serve the finished cake with homemade whipped cream and a dusting of pumpkin pie spice.

07 of 34

Slow Cooker Italian Sausage Grinders

This big-batch recipe checks all the boxes for a delicious Halloween potluck. It serves 12, comes together in your slow cooker, and calls for inexpensive pantry ingredients. On the buffet, serve the meat on split hoagie rolls topped with shredded cheese and sliced banana peppers.

08 of 34

Classic Nachos

These nachos are a classic for a reason—everyone loves them! Layer chips, beef, beans, salsa, and cheese then bake until hot and melty. Serve straight from the pan with your favorite toppings like lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and peppers.

09 of 34

Zombie Brain Cupcakes

These spooky Halloween cupcakes only look complicated to make. A boxed cake mix is the start of this easy dessert. Once baked, fill each cake with eerie green vanilla cream and use a piping bag to create the brains.

10 of 34

One-Pot Cuban-Style Barbecue Pulled Pork Sandwiches

Put a twist on classic pulled pork by adding grainy mustard and sweet relish to the sauce. Serve the shredded meat with mayo and pickle slices.

Test Kitchen Tip: Choose how long this recipe takes with our instructions to make it in the slow cooker or pressure cooker.

11 of 34

Apple-Brown Butter Bars

Apples are at their peak during Halloween. If you want a sweeter tart, choose an apple like Honeycrisp. Using tart apples like Granny Smith will produce a slightly less sweet dessert. No matter what apple you choose, a sprinkle of flaky sea salt is the perfect finish.

12 of 34

Roasted Pumpkin Guacamole

Traditional guacamole gets a makeover for fall (and Halloween) by stirring in chopped, roasted pumpkin and toasted pumpkin seeds. It's spicy, creamy, zesty, and delicious–just what you're craving when you need a break from candy. Try using this Halloween potluck idea for work, or keep the whole batch for yourself!

13 of 34

Sugared Bacon-Wrapped Smokies

With nearly 30 5-star ratings, this easy appetizer idea is truly a fan favorite. Whip up a big batch (it serves 45!) for your Halloween potluck with just three ingredients.

Test Kitchen Tip: Make the dish up to 24 hours before serving.

14 of 34

Spooky Strawberry Pumpkin Patch

Bring the pumpkin patch to your potluck! To create this easy Halloween dessert, dip fresh strawberries in orange candy coating. Plant them in a tray of homemade chocolate cookie crumbs and finish with piped green frosting vines.

15 of 34

Sweet-Spicy Barbecued Chicken Sliders

A few simple shortcuts make these saucy sliders a perfect Halloween potluck idea. Stir purchased rotisserie chicken with canned pineapple, shredded cheese, and bottled barbecue sauce. Spread on sandwich rolls and bake until golden brown and melty.

Test Kitchen Tip: Assemble the sandwiches up to eight hours before the Halloween party.

16 of 34

Pimiento Cheese Dip

You're just one step away from the ultimate Halloween potluck dip. Amp up the bold flavor with smoked cheddar cheese, cayenne pepper, and diced pimientos. Arrange the cheese dip on a platter with crackers, assorted crudites, and dill pickle chips. The tangy flavor of the pickles helps cut through the richness of the cheese.

17 of 34

Mummy Dogs

Heading to a family-friendly Halloween party? Bring a tray of buttery mummy dogs. This easy potluck recipe calls for just three inexpensive ingredients. Whip up a batch and serve them with ketchup, mustard, and barbecue sauce.

18 of 34

Halloween Oreo Ball Ghosts

These sweet ghosts combine crushed chocolate cookies, cream cheese, and mini marshmallows, then get a vanilla candy coating. The recipe makes 18, so it's a great Halloween potluck idea for work, a party, or a get-together with friends. Wherever you serve them, these ghosts will vanish in no time!

19 of 34

Tombstone Taco Dip

It's not really a party without chips and dip, and this recipe for taco dip will certainly bring the party to life. This Halloween potluck idea uses refried beans, salsa, chicken, and guacamole as the graveyard's base and baked tortillas to double as dippers and creepy tombstones. If you've got a large crowd coming, making a double batch is easy.

20 of 34

Coconut-Pumpkin Soup

Want to turn up the heat at your Halloween gathering? This sweet-and-spicy pumpkin recipe has coconut milk and jalapeño peppers to create a delicious blend of fresh flavors. The recipe serves 12, and it's a good Halloween potluck idea if you want to provide a savory option alongside all of the sweets.

21 of 34

Blood Orange Bars

The name of this recipe says it all. Blood oranges totally fit the Halloween theme and give these dessert bars a sweet citrus flavor. Bake these up to three days before your gathering.

22 of 34

Veggie Reuben Pan-Wiches

If you're planning on serving vegetarian ghouls at your party, this is the Halloween appetizer for you. As one BHG reviewer raved, "We've made these three or four times and we LOVE them. So much flavor and texture and the pretzel buns make them extra special."

23 of 34

Zarela's Pineapple-Ginger Wings

Try something new with chicken wings! Serve them with a zesty pineapple sauce and fresh lime wedges.

24 of 34

No-Bake Butterscotch Bars

Stock up on candy bars for this Halloween potluck dessert. A bag of Butterfingers is the secret to the butterscotch flavor in this big-batch sweet.

25 of 34

Spicy Roasted Red Pepper Artichoke Dip

Two kinds of peppers flavor this creamy dip recipe. If you want to make it a Halloween potluck idea, serve it with a drizzle of blood-red harissa paste and sweet potato chips.

26 of 34

Spicy Apple-Glazed Meatballs

A cup of apple juice in the sauce is the secret to this fall appetizer idea. It's the perfect recipe for Halloween parties. One BHG home cook raved, "Absolutely yummy and easy, they disappear fast—have made a couple of times and will make them again."

27 of 34

Mexican Nachos

Customize this crowd-pleasing appetizer with any one of our recipe variations. Try mole sauce or top the dish with homemade refried beans. No matter what you choose, this recipe is sure to be a crowd pleaser.

28 of 34

Apple-Cherry Chutney

If assembling a charcuterie board is your idea of cooking, this is the potluck idea for Halloween you've been looking for. A simple homemade chutney is our secret to the ultimate party appetizer.

29 of 34

Gluten-Free Tex-Mex Cheese Dip

You're two steps away from the cheesiest dip we've ever made. Balance the rich dip with pickled jalapeno slices, pico de gallo, and fresh lime juice.

30 of 34

Chicken Nachos with Wasabi Guacamole

A bit of wasabi gives these nachos just the right amount of heat. In fact, the recipe works for potlucks with kids. As one BHG home cook shared, "This was so awesome. My kids have always complained that the Nachos never had a great kick! They don't anymore."

31 of 34

Japanese Pan-Fried Chicken Gyoza

Prep these up to three months before you plan to serve them. When it comes time for the party, pan fry the gyoza and serve them with dipping sauce.

32 of 34

Gyro Nachos with Tzatziki Sauce

A slow cooker is the secret to this Halloween potluck appetizer. Pile pita chips with stewed chicken, tatziki sauce, olives, tomatoes, and dill. For even more flavor, try topping the nachos with crumbled feta cheese.

33 of 34

Slow Cooker Jalapeño Popper Dip

This dip is loaded with everything you love about jalapeno poppers, right down to the crispy topper. Serve it up with sliced veggies, crackers, and chips.

34 of 34

Air-Fried Bratwurst Bites with Spicy Beer Mustard

When cooked in the air fryer, mini peppers and sliced bratwurst become crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Serve them with your favorite dipping sauce.

Related Article

Crab Rangoon Roll-Ups Are So Much Better Than the Original

Crab Rangoon Roll-Ups Are So Much Better Than the Original

This crab rangoon roll-up recipe is the perfect balance of crispy tortilla shell and creamy crab filling. Serve them with your favorite sweet chili sauce.
Ricotta and Parmesan Spread

Ricotta and Parmesan Spread

Basil, oregano, and chives brighten up this rich Parmesan and ricotta cheese spread. Start your next dinner party with this easy, cheesy appetizer. Just add slices of baguette and veggies for dipping!
Pineapple-Ginger Punch

Pineapple-Ginger Punch

Pineapple-Ginger Punch might just be your new favorite summer drink. To transform the refreshing punch recipe into a cocktail, spike the fresh ginger-infused sip with rum or vodka.
Why You Should Be Eating More Pecans

Why You Should Be Eating More Pecans

Beyond their delicious taste, pecans are also packed to the brim with nutrition. Read on to find out just what makes pecans such a healthy addition to your lifestyle as well as some tasty ways to get started.
What Is Natural Flavor? Here’s What It Means on Food Labels

What Is Natural Flavor? Here’s What It Means on Food Labels

What does “natural flavors” mean when you see it on a food or drink label? A flavorist explains how your favorite strawberry drink gets that taste.
13 High-Protein Breakfast Ideas for a Morning Brain Boost

13 High-Protein Breakfast Ideas for a Morning Brain Boost

Looking for a protein-loaded breakfast? Here are our best energy packed breakfast ideas to give your morning a boost. Incorporate these recipes into your daily routine for a high protein breakfast.
How Long to Cook Steak on a Grill for Perfect Results Every Time

How Long to Cook Steak on a Grill for Perfect Results Every Time

Conquer your next cookout with tips on all you need to know about how long to cook steak on a grill, the best cuts to buy, and how to serve the steak.
How to Cook Eggplant—5 Simple Methods

How to Cook Eggplant—5 Simple Methods

If you're wondering how to cook eggplant, keep reading. On the grill, roasted, sautéed, and—yes—even in the microwave, this vegetable is as versatile as it is delicious.
How to Cook Sweet Potatoes—6 Different Methods Including Baked, Fried, and More

How to Cook Sweet Potatoes—6 Different Methods Including Baked, Fried, and More

Mash them, bake them, pressure-cook them, or turn them into fries—whatever your method, follow these steps to make perfect sweet potatoes every time.
Easy Chicken and Broccoli Recipes You'll Be Making on Repeat

Easy Chicken and Broccoli Recipes You'll Be Making on Repeat

From all-American casseroles to Korean-style suppers to Italian chicken Parm, these chicken and broccoli recipes show how that combo *can* be something you eagerly anticipate. We’ve rounded up our best healthy chicken and broccoli recipes (as well as a few more decadent options) to help remix your weeknight menu.
16 Cauliflower Recipes to Make if You're Cooking Tonight

16 Cauliflower Recipes to Make if You're Cooking Tonight

This round-up of cauliflower recipes features the versatile veggie as the star of the plate. Each of these recipes with cauliflower provides a wide array of options everyone can enjoy, any night of the week.
Snap Peas, Snow Peas, and Farro with Oranges and Citrus-Sesame Vinaigrette

Snap Peas, Snow Peas, and Farro with Oranges and Citrus-Sesame Vinaigrette

The crunchy combo of snap and snow peas complements the chewy bite of farro and contrasts the juicy orange sections.
Chilaquiles Breakfast Casserole

Chilaquiles Breakfast Casserole

Try this make-ahead breakfast casserole to feed a crowd on a busy weekend. The zesty Mexican flavors will inspire everyone to come back for seconds.
Fire-Roasted Tomato and Italian Sausage Grinders

Fire-Roasted Tomato and Italian Sausage Grinders

Use canned fire-roasted tomatoes to rev up this classic Italian sausage sandwich recipe.
Gluten-Free Giant Ginger Cookies

Gluten-Free Giant Ginger Cookies

We've used a 1/4 cup of cookie dough for each of these giant, molasses-infused cookies. If you prefer smaller cookies, there's instructions for mini gluten-free ginger cookies, too.
Gluten-Free Fresh Herb Vinaigrette

Gluten-Free Fresh Herb Vinaigrette

In just 10 minutes, you can have a zesty homemade salad dressing ready. The olive oil will solidify when chilled, so let the vinaigrette stand at room temperature 1 hour before serving. Don't forget to shake it well!
Portobello Pot Roast

Portobello Pot Roast

Meaty portobellos stand in for beef in this vegetarian portobello pot roast that's as rich as the classic but cooks in a fraction of the time.
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookies

Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookies

Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookies
How to Smoke Food Even if You Don't Have an Actual Smoker

How to Smoke Food Even if You Don't Have an Actual Smoker

Add complex flavors to your meats, seafood, grains, and veggies with our Test Kitchen tutorials on how to smoke food at home using a charcoal or gas grill.
Grilled Trout Stuffed with Lemon and Herbs

Grilled Trout Stuffed with Lemon and Herbs

This is a simple, flavorful way to grill almost any whole fish, with a 'stuffing' designed not to be eaten, but to flavor the fish from the inside out.